To communicate with each other, humpback whales moan,
shriek, and wail. Only in the 1960s did scientists from the New York Zoological
Society, currently known as the Wildlife Conservation Society, realize that
those wails, moans, and shrieks were, in actuality, songs. Humpback whales use
songs as a form of communication and the songs often consist of different
themes that can last for up to thirty minutes. The songs then repeat in a cycle.
Furthermore, usually whales from the same ocean basin, or the same area, sing
almost identical songs with similar themes. For example, in the Northern
Hemisphere the humpback whales sing very similar songs with almost identical
themes. However, scientists from WCS, Columbia University, and Australia
recently discovered evidence that goes against the preconceived theory that
whales from the same ocean basin sing similar songs. Scientists recently
recorded about 20 hours of whale songs and discovered that whales in the same
ocean basin are singing completely different songs. Scientists observed that
whales in the southern Indian Ocean are singing contrasting songs, which
contradicts what was usually the case. Although the reason for this oddity is
unknown, many scientists hypothesize that the transfer of songs between
different ocean basins happens at the feeding grounds and on the migration
routes. The male humpbacks usually sing the songs at winter breeding grounds
and on migrating routes, which is how whales from completely different regions
are exchanging songs. Also, since whales from the same region are singing
completely different songs, some scientists think that there is less contact
between the whales in the same ocean basin than previously thought.
The
information in this article is nothing short of revolutionary. The fact that
scientists have collected data and observations that, essentially, contradict
the previous ideas about whale songs is remarkable. The discoveries made by
these scientists have sparked a renewed interest in whale culture. Moreover,
the fact that whales from the same region are singing different songs will
supply more information on how whale culture spreads both within an ocean basin
and across different ocean basins.
From the information in this article people will see how important
scientific research is and how interesting and exciting it is. Furthermore,
Salvatore Cerchio states that if the songs of whales are continuously monitored
scientists can see where, when and how the songs are being exchanged. From
there scientists can try to figure out how to protect this unique culture in
the future. This article shows people that the cultures of all animals need to
protected and supported by the public.
This
article was written in a very bizarre format. The beginning of the article
jumps right into the recent scientific breakthrough without giving background
information that is needed to understand certain parts of the article. The very
last paragraph in the article explains what a humpback whale is and what it
looks like, however this information would have been helpful in the beginning
of the article. Overall, the order in which the information was presented
didn’t make much sense and as a result the article was, at times, difficult to
read.
Link:
http://www.biologynews.net/archives/2012/02/01/study_finds_southern_indian_ocean_humpbacks_singing_different_tunes.html
Citation:
Wildlife
Conservation Society. "Study Finds Southern Indian Ocean Humpbacks Singing
Different Tunes." Biology News Net - Latest Biology Articles, News
& Current Events.
Wildlife Conservation Society, 01 Feb. 2012. Web. 02 Feb. 2012.
<http://www.biologynews.net/archives/2012/02/01/study_finds_southern_indian_ocean_humpbacks_singing_different_tunes.html>.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteEmma what is humpback?
ReplyDeleteoh nvm its a whale i never knew that whale can sing
Emma summarized this article very well. This article was presented in an odd format with difficult language. Therefore, it is difficult to comprehend. However, Emma managed to summarize this article in a clear way, so that readers could understand it. Emma also wrote about the key points in her summary. For example, she wrote about how scientists recently taped the sounds made by whales and observed them thoroughly. Afterwards, scientists noticed that whales located in the southern Indian Ocean are not singing the same songs. This observation contradicts what scientists thought previously. Therefore, it was important for Emma to point that out. In addition, Emma also points out that whale songs can last up to thirty minutes. I like how Emma throughout her review realizes how extraordinary and interesting whale communications can be. Since scientists can record whale sounds, they can figure out when, where, and how songs are taking place. It is essential that Emma put Wildlife Conservation Society and Columbia University as references in her review to let people know that these sources are not only reliable, but also devote a substantial portion of their research to various subsections of marine biology.
ReplyDeleteAlthough Emma did a decent job reviewing this article, she was extremely repetitive. She mentioned the whale song contradiction several times throughout her review. The other information that was stated could have been more in depth. In addition, Emma could have written about her own opinions and values about humpback whales in general as well as their songs. This suggestion could be necessary because it could spark questions about these whales, and it could lead into more research about these songs.
I was unaware about how remarkable whale songs could be. I never researched the significance of whale songs and scientists’ observations about them, but after reading this article as well as Emma’s review, it sparked a lot of interest in me. It is amazing how humpback whales from the same region are singing completely different songs.
The reviewer did a good job of helping me understand the article more by making things more clear. It helped explain how the whales communicated by songs with similar themes. It was interesting that hump back whales in the northern Hemisphere comminuted in similar tunes to other whales in their same basin, where are whales communicating in Australia in the same basin as them sing completing different tunes to communicate. She made the information very clear including when she explained when the males sing and why. I agree with Emma that some background information would have well, to help the reader understand the humpback whales even more.
ReplyDeleteEven though Emma did a great job, it would have been interesting what she that thought of the article and the new discoveries. There was a few repeats of ideas but I thought it really made the reader understand the new discovers.
I didn’t know that whales communicated by singing in themes to one another, I found this very interesting. It is also great that more and more new thing s is being discovered about these animals.
All in all, Emma’s review of “Study Finds Southern Indian Ocean Humpbacks Singing Different Tunes” was superb. I think Emma did a great job trying to explain this complicated topic. The article seemed to be quite confusing so Emma’s effort in trying to summarize the difficult article was great. Considering the difficulty of this article, I thought Emma, for the most part, used pretty simple, common words, making it easier for the reader, of her review. Lastly, Emma’s critique of the article was well written and I completely agree with what she said.
ReplyDeleteI thought that Emma’s second paragraph of her review was a little confusing. I completely understand and take in to account that the article was slightly confusing but I was not quite sure what Emma was trying to say, or what point she was trying to prove, in that paragraph. Also, some of the sentences, such as the last sentence in the first paragraph, were a little confusing to me. I’m sure Emma was explaining it as well as she could, from the information given by the article, but I was not too sure what it all meant.
I found it interesting to learn about whales’ songs to each other. I knew they communicated through “singing” but I never thought there was more to it. I found it fascinating that whales in the same “ocean basin” sung completely different songs.
I think Emma did great job on writing about this whale. I learned many things from reading her review and it was fun and interesting article. I never knew that whale can sing like that the things that I didn’t understand was that how do we know that whale is making sound.
ReplyDeletei had confusion on 2nd paragraoh because of my understanding the english but after i translate i still had problem with understanding. i was confusinf on efw of the last sentences on the last part of paragraph 1.
it was very interseting to me to learn about a whale the sings and i neverknew. now i have new intersting imformasion to tell to my little brother.